Miller’s Girl: A Profound Dive into the Unconventional and Utterly Bonkers Cinematic Experience


In the realm of cinema, there exists a peculiar genre known as the “Completely Bonkers Cinematic Canon.” This exclusive club is reserved for films that unabashedly embrace their own absurdity, refusing to conform to conventional storytelling norms. They possess an uncanny ability to transport viewers into a world where logic takes a backseat and the bizarre reigns supreme. Enter “Miller’s Girl,” the latest addition to this esteemed category, a film that revels in its own eccentricity, leaving audiences both bewildered and strangely entertained.


Miller’s Girl: A Cinematic Enigma

Released in 2024, “Miller’s Girl” is the brainchild of Jade Halley Bartlett, a filmmaker with a penchant for pushing boundaries and challenging cinematic conventions. The film stars Jenna Ortega, fresh off her success in the popular series “Wednesday,” as Cairo Sweet, a peculiar young woman with a penchant for the written word and a yearning for a life beyond the confines of her isolated existence. Surrounded by books and antique birdcages, Cairo resides in an antebellum mansion in rural Tennessee, her only companions being her imagination and the echoes of her absent parents, powerful lawyers constantly globe-trotting for work.


A Twisted Tale of Desire and Deception

The narrative unfolds through Cairo’s deadpan voiceover, introducing us to her lonely and unremarkable life. Her sole aspiration is to “meet a writer,” a desire that fuels her determination to attend high school, a place she believes holds the key to unlocking her literary dreams. However, the title “Miller’s Girl” carries a dual meaning, as Cairo’s English teacher, the aforementioned writer, is named Jonathan Miller, played by the talented Martin Freeman. Adding another layer of intrigue, Cairo harbors a fascination for the controversial novelist Henry Miller, whose erotic novel “Under the Roofs of Paris” she brazenly brings to her first day of class, along with a copy of Jonathan’s unsuccessful collection of romantic short stories, “Apostrophes and Ampersands.”


A Quirky Cast of Characters

In this peculiar high school, there appear to be only two teachers, Mr. Miller and Coach Fillmore (Bashir Salahuddin), and two students, Cairo and her vivacious best friend Winnie (Gideon Adlon), whose catchphrase, “hungy,” adds a touch of levity to the film’s otherwise surreal atmosphere. Together, the girls concoct a plan to seduce their teachers, primarily driven by Winnie’s infatuation with Coach Fillmore and Cairo’s need for a compelling topic for her college admissions essay, which requires her to write about her greatest accomplishment. Attempting to decipher the logic behind this wacky screenplay is an exercise in futility.


A Visual Feast of Eccentricity

“Miller’s Girl” is not without its flaws. Bartlett’s directorial choices sometimes raise eyebrows, particularly in terms of camera placement during significant moments. Yet, the film’s delirious style, coupled with Cheyenne Ford’s intricate production design, creates a visually captivating experience. Jonathan’s classroom is a dimly lit haven adorned with Persian rugs, while Cairo’s “ancestral home” is a treasure trove of taxidermy, teacups, and vintage rotary phones.


A Dialogue-Heavy Script

However, the film’s most striking feature is Bartlett’s script, which elevates the phrase “tortured prose” to new heights. The narration is laden with portentous overtones, while the rapid-fire dialogue puts even the fast-paced banter of “Gilmore Girls” to shame. Jonathan’s declaration of Cairo’s genius solely based on her ability to use the word “vituperation” in a sentence epitomizes the film’s penchant for linguistic excess. “Miller’s Girl” could aptly be described as “Thesaurus: The Movie.”


Exploring Sexuality Through Words

The film’s exploration of sexuality is confined entirely to the realm of words. Jonathan and his workaholic wife, Beatrice (Dagmara Dominczyk), engage in verbal seduction, while his inappropriate flirtation with Cairo spirals out of control. He assigns her a special midterm assignment, challenging her to write in the style of her favorite author, Henry Miller. Cairo wholeheartedly embraces the task, crafting an erotic essay so audacious that it culminates in a messy climax, both figuratively and literally.


A Guilty Pleasure with a Unique Charm

Despite its unconventional narrative and questionable character development, “Miller’s Girl” possesses an undeniable verve. The cast revels in the film’s Southern Gothic atmosphere, particularly Dominczyk, who fully embodies the Blanche DuBois-esque character of Beatrice. Clad in a bra and satin robe, perpetually surrounded by stacks of paper and bottles of liquor, Beatrice takes evident pleasure in verbally sparring with Jonathan, emasculating him at every turn. Cairo, too, delights in tormenting Jonathan, whom she dismissively labels a “madman,” despite his apparent horniness and henpecked demeanor.


A Cinematic Enigma that Defies Conventions

“Miller’s Girl” is a cinematic enigma, a film that defies conventional wisdom and revels in its own absurdity. It is a love letter to the Completely Bonkers Cinematic Canon, a genre that thrives on its lack of self-awareness and its ability to transport viewers to a world where the ordinary gives way to the extraordinary. Whether you embrace its eccentricities or find yourself baffled by its audacity, “Miller’s Girl” will undoubtedly leave a lasting impression, proving once again that cinema has the power to surprise, challenge, and entertain in equal measure.


Call to Action

Have you had the chance to experience the cinematic rollercoaster that is “Miller’s Girl”? Share your thoughts and feelings about this unconventional film in the comments section below. Are you a fan of the Completely Bonkers Cinematic Canon, or do you prefer films that follow a more traditional narrative structure? Join the conversation and let’s delve deeper into the world of unconventional and utterly bonkers cinema.