Critics Were Once Our Best Guides to New Music. Then Came Streaming and AI

The Fall of Pitchfork: A Tale of Two Eras

Once upon a time, in the realm of music criticism, Pitchfork reigned supreme. Founded in 1996, this digital publication ascended to prominence in the early 2000s, captivating music enthusiasts with its incisive reviews, bold opinions, and uncanny ability to predict the next big thing. Pitchfork wasn’t just a music review site; it was a cultural phenomenon, shaping tastes, sparking debates, and defining the zeitgeist of independent music.

However, like all empires, Pitchfork’s reign faced the tides of change. The advent of streaming services, coupled with the rise of artificial intelligence (AI), has irrevocably altered the landscape of music consumption and criticism. This article delves into the factors that led to Pitchfork’s decline and explores the broader challenges confronting music critics in the digital age.

Economic Headwinds: The Changing Tides of Digital Media

The economic challenges that have plagued the media industry in recent years have not spared Pitchfork. The decline of advertising revenue, exacerbated by the dominance of tech giants like Google and Meta, has left many publications struggling to stay afloat. Pitchfork, despite its critical acclaim, was not immune to these financial pressures.

The rise of generative AI, particularly Google’s increasing reliance on its search generative experience product, has further intensified the competition for online advertising revenue. As AI-generated content becomes more sophisticated and indistinguishable from human-written text, publishers face an uphill battle to capture readers’ attention and advertising dollars.

Editorial Shifts: The Changing Role of Music Critics

The advent of streaming services has fundamentally changed the way people discover and consume music. Gone are the days when music fans eagerly awaited the latest issue of Pitchfork or other music magazines to guide their listening habits. Today, Spotify’s personalized playlists, powered by AI algorithms, have become the de facto tastemakers, curating music experiences tailored to individual preferences.

While AI-driven recommendations can be effective in suggesting new music, they often lack the depth, context, and critical perspective that human critics provide. Music critics, with their expertise and passion, can offer insights into the artistic merits, historical significance, and cultural impact of music that AI algorithms simply cannot replicate.

The Loss of Cultural Discourse: A Fragmented Music Landscape

The decline of music criticism has led to a fragmentation of cultural conversations around music. In the past, music critics served as gatekeepers, shaping the broader discourse and helping to establish a shared understanding of what constituted good music. Today, contemporary music culture is more focused on fandoms and individual artists than on broader discussions about trends, genres, and the evolution of music.

This fragmentation has resulted in a loss of critical perspective and a diminished ability to engage in meaningful discussions about the cultural significance of music. Music criticism, at its best, can provide a lens through which we can understand and appreciate music in its broader context, fostering a deeper understanding of its impact on society and culture.

The Future of Music Criticism: Adapting to the Digital Age

Despite the challenges facing music criticism, there is still a need for thoughtful and informed criticism in the digital age. Music critics must adapt to new platforms and find innovative ways to engage with audiences while maintaining their role as guides and interpreters of music.

One way forward is for critics to embrace the strengths of digital media. Online platforms offer unprecedented opportunities for critics to connect with readers, share their insights, and engage in real-time discussions about music. Critics can also leverage multimedia formats, such as podcasts, videos, and interactive content, to create more engaging and immersive experiences for their audiences.

Another key to the survival of music criticism is collaboration. Critics can join forces with other stakeholders in the music industry, such as artists, labels, and promoters, to create new platforms and initiatives that support and promote critical writing about music. By working together, these stakeholders can ensure that music criticism remains a vital part of the music ecosystem.

Conclusion: The Enduring Legacy of Pitchfork and the Path Forward

Pitchfork’s influence on music criticism cannot be understated. The publication’s legacy lies in its ability to shape tastes, discover new artists, and foster critical discourse around music. While Pitchfork’s decline is a sign of the changing times, it also presents an opportunity for music critics to adapt, innovate, and find new ways to engage with audiences in the digital age.

The challenges facing music criticism are significant, but they are not insurmountable. By embracing new technologies, collaborating with other stakeholders, and continuing to provide insightful and thought-provoking criticism, music critics can ensure that their voices continue to be heard and valued in the ever-evolving world of music.

Additional Resources:

– Kyle Chayka’s book on algorithms flattening culture:
(https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/587760/the-longing-for-less-by-kyle-chayka/)

– David Yaffe-Bellany’s appearance on The Ezra Klein Show:
(https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/18/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-david-yaffe-bellany.html)

– New York’s John Herrman on selling a used mechanical pencil on TikTok:
(https://www.nytimes.com/2023/01/10/technology/tiktok-selling-used-items.html)

Contact Information:

Readers are encouraged to send tips, comments, questions, and their favorite Pitchfork reviews to [email protected] and [email protected].

Social Media:

Follow Casey’s Instagram stories for more insightful content:
(https://www.instagram.com/caseynewton/)

Event:

Bay Area readers are invited to attend Zoë’s book launch event on February 13 at Manny’s in San Francisco.
(https://www.mannys.com/)