Clash in Court: Trump Defies Judge, Faces Removal Threat in Defamation Trial

January 18, 2024


Trump’s Tumultuous Courtroom Behavior Continues

In a dramatic turn of events, former President Donald Trump clashed with Judge Lewis Kaplan during the civil defamation trial brought against him by E. Jean Carroll, who accused him of sexual assault. The heated exchange highlighted Trump’s disruptive behavior in court, raising concerns about his conduct in potential future criminal trials.

Trump’s Presence Disrupts Trial Proceedings

Trump’s arrival in the courtroom immediately disrupted the trial’s proceedings. Carroll’s attorney, Shawn Crowley, complained that Trump’s audible commentary could be overheard by the jury during breaks. Despite Judge Kaplan’s warning to keep his voice down, Trump continued to make disruptive remarks, prompting the judge to issue a stern warning. Kaplan explicitly stated that Trump’s disruptive behavior could result in his removal from the trial.

Trump’s Disruptive History in Court

This incident is not an isolated case, as Trump has a history of disruptive behavior in court. During his civil fraud trial in New York state court, Judge Arthur Engoron warned Trump that he could be removed as a witness for launching into political speeches. The judge even called Trump to the witness stand for impromptu questioning after Trump’s comments violated the court’s gag order.

Trump’s Potential Testimony and Restrictions

Despite the judge’s warning, Trump could still testify in the defamation case. However, Judge Kaplan has ruled that Trump cannot testify that he didn’t assault Carroll or that she lied about the rape allegation. These questions have already been decided by a civil jury in last year’s trial.

Carroll’s Testimony: A Harrowing Account of Threats and Fear

E. Jean Carroll took the stand and recounted the devastating impact Trump’s statements had on her life after she went public with her sexual assault allegations. She described the onslaught of threatening messages, the safety precautions she had to take, and the constant fear she lived in. Carroll’s testimony painted a vivid picture of the emotional toll Trump’s actions had on her.

Trump’s Lawyers Engage in Disputes with the Judge

Trump’s lawyers also engaged in several disputes with Judge Kaplan. They requested a mistrial due to the deleted threatening messages, which was promptly denied. They also asked the judge to recuse himself, citing a perceived hostility towards Trump and his legal team, but the judge rejected this request as well.

Trump’s Absence from Trial and Future Court Appearances

Trump is expected to be absent from the trial on Thursday as he travels to Florida for his mother-in-law’s funeral. Judge Kaplan denied Trump’s request to postpone the trial in his absence. If the defense calls Trump as a witness, they can do so on Monday even if the rest of the case wraps up on Thursday.

Trump’s Limited Access to Media Coverage

Unlike the Trump Org. civil fraud trial, Trump does not have easy access to a camera at the federal courthouse where the civil defamation trial is taking place. Instead, he turned to his property at 40 Wall Street, a mile south of the courthouse, to make a statement attacking the judge and reiterating his claims about not knowing Carroll.

Concerns about Trump’s Behavior in Potential Criminal Trials

Trump’s conduct in the civil defamation trial has raised concerns about his behavior in potential future criminal trials. If Trump’s disruptive behavior continues, it could hinder the fair administration of justice and undermine the integrity of the legal process. The upcoming trials will be closely watched to assess Trump’s ability to adhere to court rules and decorum.


Disclaimer: This blog post is for informational purposes only and should not be taken as legal advice.